Background: Eclectic treatment method is a flexible approach that uses techniques drawn from various schools of thought involving several treatment methods and allows the therapist to adapt to each client’s individual needs. Wider application for eclectic approach is however limited in stroke rehabilitation. Aim: The objective is to find out whether eclectic approach improves upper extremity (UE) functional recovery in acute stroke rehabilitation. Methodology: Twenty-five postacute unilateral supratentorial stroke subjects recruited from tertiary care hospitals recovered with Stage 2–5 in Brunnstorm stage of UE motor recovery (BRS-UE) underwent 45 min of eclectic approach for UE every day involving seven different treatment methods (5 min for each method) for 6 days consecutively. The outcome was UE subscale of the Fugl-Meyer Motor test (UE-FM), UE subscale of the Stroke Rehabilitation Assessment of Movement (UE-STREAM), Wolf Motor Function test (WMFT-FAS), and Stroke Impact Scale-16 (SIS-16) was collected at the end of the sixth session. Results: All the participants showed significant improvement in all the outcome measures. The Stage 2 and 3 subjects showed UE-STREAM (P = 0.007) WMFT-FAS (P < 0.001), SIS (P = 0.023) respectively and for Stage 4 and 5 the subjects have shown UE FM (P < 0.001), WMFT-FAS (P < 0.001), SIS (P = 0.004) with large magnitude of treatment effect for all stages of BRS-UE. Conclusion: Our study findings are in favor of integrating eclectic approach than single intervention/approach in clinical practice to improve the UE functional recovery for motor rehabilitation when the stroke occurs.
Globally, stroke is the third major cause of mortality and a major health issue in low- and middle-income countries like India.Eighty percent of stroke survivors experience motor impairments (hemiparesis) typically affecting movement of the face, arm, trunk, and leg of one side of the body often persistent and disabling them. These residual impairments limit their functional independence and predisposing them to restrict their participation in community and social roles.,
Upper limb hemiparesis is one of the primary impairments following the stroke. It is often reported to be incomplete in functional recovery and to restore the motor skills. The studies on recovery of voluntary arm movements have also shown that 5–20% of stroke survivors achieved complete functional recovery and 30–60% of paretic arm can never have complete recovery during the first 6 months after the stroke., Common upper extremity (UE) impairments after the stroke include paresis, loss of fractionated movement, abnormal muscle tone and/or changes in somatosensation, shoulder pain, and subluxation which prevents the functional use of the arm, bimanual tasks and also for fine motor skills., Post stroke, persistent arm motor impairment (a period of 1 year or above) can be associated with anxiety and poorer perception of health-related quality of life and subjective well-being.,
One of the primary aims of the stroke rehabilitation is to improve the arm functions and to regain the gross and fine motor skills. Currently, the existing rehabilitation protocols that are designed to improve UE functions include the various treatment methods/interventions such as Roods, Brunnstorm, proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation, neuro-developmental therapy techniques, repetitive/task-specific training, strength training, sensorimotor interventions, constraint-induced movement therapy, virtual reality, spasticity treatment, electromyographic/biofeedback, transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation, neuromuscular electrical stimulation, functional electric stimulation, motor imagery, mirror therapy, and bilateral arm training. However, recent systematic reviews have concluded that there is insufficient evidence observed for any intervention or approach that can currently be used in routine practice to improve the paretic upper limb functions.
An eclectic therapy is a therapeutic approach that incorporates a variety of therapeutic principles and philosophies to create the ideal treatment program to meet the specific needs of the patient or client. The intervention of an eclectic approach is based on the stable principles of the classic traditional methods but is open to refining and can be used in conjunction with the elements of other various new methods, thus providing a framework for designing an optimal neurorehabilitation protocol., The studies have shown that the eclectic approach is suitable for a diverse and complex set of patients.,, However, wider application of eclectic approach in stroke rehabilitation is limited in literature.