Abstract
Objective:
To evaluate (1) the effectiveness of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) at improving lower extremity motor recovery in stroke survivors and (2) the optimal stimulation parameters for TENS.
Review methods:
A systematic search was conducted for studies published up to October 2017 using eight electronic databases (CINAHL, ClinicalTrials.gov, the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, EMBASE, MEDLINE, PEDro, PubMed and Web of Science). Randomized controlled trials that evaluated the effectiveness of the application of TENS at improving lower extremity motor recovery in stroke survivors were assessed for inclusion. Outcomes of interest included plantar flexor spasticity, muscle strength, walking capacity and balance.
Results:
In all, 11 studies met the inclusion criteria which involved 439 stroke survivors. The meta-analysis showed that TENS improved walking capacity, as measured by either gait speed or the Timed Up and Go Test (Hedges’ g = 0.392; 95% confidence interval (CI) = 0.178 to 0.606) compared to the placebo or no-treatment control groups. TENS also reduced paretic plantar flexor spasticity, as measured using the Modified Ashworth Scale and Composite Spasticity Scale (Hedges’ g = –0.884; 95% CI = –1.140 to −0.625). The effect of TENS on walking capacity in studies involving 60 minutes per sessions was significant (Hedges’ g = 0.468; 95% CI = 0.201–0.734) but not in study with shorter sessions (20 or 30 minutes) (Hedges’ g = 0.254; 95% CI = –0.106–0.614).
References
| 1. | Levin, MF, Huichan, CWY. Relief of hemiparetic spasticity by TENS is associated with improvement in reflex and voluntary motor functions. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 1992; 85(2): 131–142. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 2. | Chen, SC, Chen, YL, Chen, CJ. Effects of surface electrical stimulation on the muscle-tendon junction of spastic gastrocnemius in stroke patients. Disabil Rehabil 2005; 27(3): 105–110. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 3. | Cho, HY, In, TS, Cho, KH. A single trial of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) improves spasticity and balance in patients with chronic stroke. Tohoku J Exp Med 2013; 229(3): 187–193. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 4. | Karakoyun, A, Boyraz, I, Gunduz, R. Electrophysiological and clinical evaluation of the effects of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation on the spasticity in the hemiplegic stroke patients. J Phys Ther Sci 2015; 27(11): 3407–3411. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 5. | Martins, FL, Carvalho, LC, Silva, CC. Immediate effects of TENS and cryotherapy in the reflex excitability and voluntary activity in hemiparetic subjects: a randomized crossover trial. Rev Bras Fisioter 2012; 16(4): 337–344, http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/o/cochrane/clcentral/articles/844/CN-00869844/frame.html Google Scholar |
| 6. | Sonde, L, Kalimo, H, Viitanen, M. Stimulation with high-frequency TENS-Effects on lower limb spasticity after stroke. Adv Physiother 2000; 2(4): 183–187. Google Scholar, Crossref |
| 7. | Yan, T, Hui-Chan, CW. Transcutaneous electrical stimulation on acupuncture points improves muscle function in subjects after acute stroke: a randomized controlled trial. J Rehabil Med 2009; 41(5): 312–316. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 8. | Tyson, SF, Sadeghi-Demneh, E, Nester, CJ. The effects of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation on strength, proprioception, balance and mobility in people with stroke: a randomized controlled cross-over trial. Clin Rehabil 2013; 27(9): 785–791. Google Scholar, Link |
| 9. | Hussain, T, Mohammad, H. The effect of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) combined with Bobath on post stroke spasticity. A randomized controlled study. J Neurol Sci 2013; 333: e560. Google Scholar, Crossref |
| 10. | Ng, SS, Hui-Chan, CW. Does the use of TENS increase the effectiveness of exercise for improving walking after stroke? A randomized controlled clinical trial. Clin Rehabil 2009; 23(12): 1093–1103. Google Scholar, Link |
| 11. | Ng, SS, Hui-Chan, CW. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation combined with task-related training improves lower limb functions in subjects with chronic stroke. Stroke 2007; 38(11): 2953–2959. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 12. | Hiraoka, K. Neural mechanisms underlying the effect of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation in humans. Electromyogr Clin Neurophysiol 2002; 42(6): 359–366. Google Scholar, Medline |
| 13. | Veerbeek, JM, van Wegen, E, van Peppen, R. What is the evidence for physical therapy poststroke? A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS ONE 2014; 9(2): e87987. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 14. | Mills, PB, Dossa, F. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation for management of limb spasticity: a systematic review. Am J Phys Med Rehabil 2016; 95(4): 309–318. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 15. | Ng, SS, Lai, CW, Tang, MW. Cutaneous electrical stimulation to improve balance performance in patients with sub-acute stroke: a randomised controlled trial. Hong Kong Med J 2016; 22(Suppl 2): S33–S36. Google Scholar, Medline |
| 16. | Jung, KS, In, TS, Cho, HY. Effects of sit-to-stand training combined with transcutaneous electrical stimulation on spasticity, muscle strength and balance ability in patients with stroke: A randomized controlled study. Gait Posture 2017; 54: 183–187. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 17. | Park, J, Seo, D, Choi, W. The effects of exercise with TENS on spasticity, balance, and gait in patients with chronic stroke: a randomized controlled trial. Med Sci Monit 2014; 20: 1890–1896. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 18. | Kumar, C, Kulkarni, CM. Comparison between electrical stimulation over motor point and TENS over acupuncture point in reducing spasticity and improving function after stroke: randomized clinical trial. Int J Phys Med Rehabil 2014; 2(6): 237. Google Scholar |
| 19. | Moseley, AM, Herbert, RD, Sherrington, C. Evidence for physiotherapy practice: a survey of the Physiotherapy Evidence Database (PEDro). Aust J Physiother 2002; 48(1): 43–49. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 20. | Ng, SS, Hui-Chan, CW. The timed up & go test: its reliability and association with lower-limb impairments and locomotor capacities in people with chronic stroke. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2005; 86(8): 1641–1647. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 21. | Feiveson, AH. What is the delta method and how is it used to estimate the standard error of a transformed parameter? 2005, http://www.stata.com/support/faqs/statistics/delta-method/ Google Scholar |
| 22. | Hedges, LV, Olkin, I. Statistical methods for meta-analysis. Orland, FL: Academic Press, 2014. Google Scholar |
| 23. | Higgins, JPT, Green, S. Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011]. The Cochrane Collaboration, 2011, http://handbook.cochrane.org. Google Scholar |
| 24. | Egger, M, Davey Smith, G, Schneider, M. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ 1997; 315(7109): 629–634. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 25. | Foley, NC, Teasell, RW, Bhogal, SK. Stroke rehabilitation evidence-based review: methodology. Top Stroke Rehabil 2003; 10(1): 1–7. Google Scholar, Crossref |
| 26. | Thompson, SG, Higgins, J. How should meta-regression analyses be undertaken and interpreted? Stat Med 2002; 21(11): 1559–1573. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 27. | Yavuzer, G, Oken, O, Atay, MB. Effect of sensory-amplitude electric stimulation on motor recovery and gait kinematics after stroke: a randomized controlled study. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2007; 88(6): 710–714. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 28. | Deshmukh, MK, Kumar, C, Goyal, M. Application of transcutaneous electrical stimulation on lower limb acupoints as an important adjunctive tool in stroke rehabilitation program & its effects on spasticity and functional ability. Int J Physioth Res 2013; 3: 63–67. Google Scholar |
| 29. | Tekeolu, Yb, Adak, B, Göksoy, T. Effect of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) on Barthel Activities of Daily Living (ADL) index score following stroke. Clin Rehabil 1998; 12(4): 277–280. Google Scholar, Link |
| 30. | Hui-Chan, CW, Ng, SS, Mak, MK. Effectiveness of a home-based rehabilitation programme on lower limb functions after stroke. Hong Kong Med J 2009; 15(3, Suppl 4): 42–46. Google Scholar, Medline |
| 31. | Sonde, L, Kalimo, H, Fernaeus, SE. Low TENS treatment on post-stroke paretic arm: a three-year follow-up. Clin Rehabil 2000; 14(1): 14–19. Google Scholar, Link |
| 32. | Sonde, L, Gip, C, Fernaeus, SE. Stimulation with low frequency (1.7 Hz) transcutaneous electric nerve stimulation (low-TENS) increases motor function of the post-stroke paretic arm. Scand J Rehabil Med 1998; 30(2): 95–99. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 33. | Bakheit, AMO, Maynard, VA, Curnow, J. The relation between Ashworth scale scores and the excitability of the alpha motor neurones in patients with post-stroke muscle spasticity. J Neurol Neurosur Ps 2003; 74(5): 646–648. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 34. | Patrick, E, Ada, L. The Tardieu Scale differentiates contracture from spasticity whereas the Ashworth Scale is confounded by it. Clin Rehabil 2006; 20(2): 173–182. Google Scholar, Link |
| 35. | Ng, SS, Hui-Chan, CW. Ankle dorsiflexion, not plantarflexion strength, predicts the functional mobility of people with spastic Hemiplegia. J Rehabil Med 2013; 45(6): 541–545. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 36. | Lomaglio, MJ, Eng, JJ. Muscle strength and weight-bearing symmetry relate to sit-to-stand performance in individuals with stroke. Gait Posture 2005; 22(2): 126–131. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 37. | Koyama, S, Tanabe, S, Takeda, K. Modulation of spinal inhibitory reflexes depends on the frequency of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation in spastic stroke survivors. Somatosens Mot Res 2016; 33(1): 8–15. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 38. | Laddha, D, Ganesh, GS, Pattnaik, M. Effect of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation on plantar flexor muscle spasticity and walking speed in stroke patients. Physiother Res Int 2016; 21(4): 247–256. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 39. | Duncan, PW, Goldstein, LB, Horner, RD. Similar motor recovery of upper and lower extremities after stroke. Stroke 1994; 25(6): 1181–1188. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 40. | Kaneko, T, Caria, MA, Asanuma, H. Information processing within the motor cortex. II. Intracortical connections between neurons receiving somatosensory cortical input and motor output neurons of the cortex. J Comp Neurol 1994; 345(2): 172–184. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 41. | Lai, MI, Pan, LL, Tsai, MW. Investigating the effects of peripheral electrical stimulation on corticomuscular functional connectivity stroke survivors. Top Stroke Rehabil 2016; 23(3): 154–162. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
| 42. | Veldman, MP, Zijdewind, I, Solnik, S. Direct and crossed effects of somatosensory electrical stimulation on motor learning and neuronal plasticity in humans. Eur J Appl Physiol 2015; 115(12): 2505–2519. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline |
TBI Rehabilitation 