Posts Tagged Motor
There is growing interest in using biomarkers to predict motor recovery and outcomes after stroke. The PREP2 algorithm combines clinical assessment with biomarkers in an algorithm, to predict upper limb functional outcomes for individual patients. To date, PREP2 is the first algorithm to be tested in clinical practice, and other biomarker-based algorithms are likely to follow.
This review considers how algorithms to predict motor recovery and outcomes after stroke might be implemented in clinical practice.
There are two tasks: first the prediction information needs to be obtained, and then it needs to be used. The barriers and facilitators of implementation are likely to differ for these tasks. We identify specific elements of the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research that are relevant to each of these two tasks, using the PREP2 algorithm as an example. These include the characteristics of the predictors and algorithm, the clinical setting and its staff, and the healthcare environment.
Active, theoretically underpinned implementation strategies are needed to ensure that biomarkers are successfully used in clinical practice for predicting motor outcomes after stroke, and should be considered in parallel with biomarker development.
[Thesis] Post-stroke rehabilitation of hand function based on Electromyography biofeedback – Full Text PDF
The aim of my thesis work is the application and validation of an electromyographic biofeedback (EMG-BF) system in post-stroke rehabilitation setting. The absolute number of strokes is expected to dramatically increase in coming years, thus suggesting a need for strategies to improve post-stroke assistance and rehabilitation. The electromyogram (EMG) signal has shown good perspectives in the analysis of movements and motor impairment and the introduction of closed loop rehabilitation strategies revealed an increase of patient self-consciousness and motivation. Results are promising but a lack in the optimization of the devices for the application in the clinical context has been revealed. The device and the related software employed in the present research have been specifically conceived with this purpose. The device has been optimized during a clinical pilot study and then, a complete clinical trial has been started to investigate the characteristics of post stroke patients eligible for a rehabilitation therapy with the device, and the short-term clinical effect of the therapy on the recovery of the hand functionality. A statistical analysis has been performed on the dataset collected for 3 months. The data analysis included both clinical data and data collected from patients with the device during the execution of the experimental protocol. The preliminary results of the data analysis have confirmed the suitability of the system for its intended use and highlighted that the patient ability of controlling the EMG-BF based device is related to the degree of impairment with minimum p-value<0.001, depending on the patient clinical picture and on the exercise performed.
Moreover, according preliminary results observed on four patients that received a 15 hours therapy for 3 weeks, the improvement of the parameters related to the hand and fingers motor function, suggests the efficacy of the therapy. Finally, aspects related to the analysis of continuous motions of the wrist performed during the therapy have been investigated and the relevance of the temporal information in the interpretation of this type of movements has been revealed (p<<0.01).
[Systematic Review] Trends in robot-assisted and virtual reality-assisted neuromuscular therapy: a systematic review of health-related multiplayer games – Full Text
Multiplayer games have emerged as a promising approach to increase the motivation of patients involved in rehabilitation therapy. In this systematic review, we evaluated recent publications in health-related multiplayer games that involved patients with cognitive and/or motor impairments. The aim was to investigate the effect of multiplayer gaming on game experience and game performance in healthy and non-healthy populations in comparison to individual game play. We further discuss the publications within the context of the theory of flow and the challenge point framework.
A systematic search was conducted through EMBASE, Medline, PubMed, Cochrane, CINAHL and PsycINFO. The search was complemented by recent publications in robot-assisted multiplayer neurorehabilitation. The search was restricted to robot-assisted or virtual reality-based training.
Thirteen articles met the inclusion criteria. Multiplayer modes used in health-related multiplayer games were: competitive, collaborative and co-active multiplayer modes. Multiplayer modes positively affected game experience in nine studies and game performance in six studies. Two articles reported increased game performance in single-player mode when compared to multiplayer mode.
The multiplayer modes of training reviewed improved game experience and game performance compared to single-player modes. However, the methods reviewed were quite heterogeneous and not exhaustive. One important take-away is that adaptation of the game conditions can individualize the difficulty of a game to a player’s skill level in competitive multiplayer games. Robotic assistance and virtual reality can enhance individualization by, for example, adapting the haptic conditions, e.g. by increasing haptic support or by providing haptic resistance. The flow theory and the challenge point framework support these results and are used in this review to frame the idea of adapting players’ game conditions.
Robotic assistance and virtual reality in neuromuscular therapy
Neurological deficits can result in impaired motor function that affect a person’s quality of life. Researchers have been working to restore the nervous system and reduce the neurological deficits of people suffering from stroke, spinal cord injury, or traumatic brain injury . For people with neurological deficits, impaired motor function is among the most prominent factors limiting the quality of life . Motor neurorehabilitation can lead to permanent improvements in motor function . Robotic assistance and virtual reality have the potential to enhance rehabilitation of neuromuscular deficits beyond the levels possible with conventional training strategies [4, 5].
Game experience and task performance in multiplayer games
Robot- and virtual reality-assisted single-player games are well integrated in neurorehabilitation schedules. Recently, multiplayer games have been tested to complement neuromuscular therapy. Multiplayer games are expected to motivate the patients and increase the potential of robot- and virtual reality-assisted neuromuscular therapy.
Multiplayer games incorporate social interaction to promote the enjoyment of the involved players. The additional player adds new possibilities to the game environment, generally missed in single-player gaming against preprogrammed challenges or artificially controlled opponents. The multiplayer environment and related game mechanics can facilitate social interaction, ranging from conversation to haptic interaction. Due to the this added social interaction, the game experience is thought to be better in multiplayer compared to single-player gaming .
The mode of the game specifies whether the players compete or cooperate with one another . In line with the flow theory, a competitive mode requires opponents of similar skill level to achieve enjoyment as the task difficulty experienced by one opponent . Comparable skill levels prevent boredom or stress and result in a meaningful challenge level that leads to a flow state when training . In such training conditions the players have a positive game experience.
In positive game experience players increase their game performance [9, 10]. Increased game performance facilitates the general idea of serious games, i.e., playing for a primary purpose other than pure entertainment . If enhanced game performance is achieved by increased physical activity, training intensity is also increased. In neuromuscular therapy, training intensity – alongside early treatment, user-centered, and task-oriented training – is one of the key factors in neurorehabilitation [12, 13]. Therefore, multiplayer gaming has great potential to further increase the benefits of robot-assisted neuromuscular and virtual reality-assisted therapy [14, 15].
Continue —> Trends in robot-assisted and virtual reality-assisted neuromuscular therapy: a systematic review of health-related multiplayer games | Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation | Full Text
Tele-rehabilitation for stroke survivors has emerged as a promising intervention for remotely supervised administration of physical, occupational, speech, and other forms of therapies aimed at improving motor, cognitive, and neuropsychiatric deficits from stroke.
We aimed to provide an updated systematic review on the efficacy of tele-rehabilitation interventions for recovery from motor, higher cortical dysfunction, and poststroke depression among stroke survivors.
We searched PubMed and Cochrane library from January 1, 1980 to July 15, 2017 using the following keywords: “Telerehabilitation stroke,” “Mobile health rehabilitation,” “Telemedicine stroke rehabilitation,” and “Telerehabilitation.” Our inclusion criteria were randomized controlled trials, pilot trials, or feasibility trials that included an intervention group that received any tele-rehabilitation therapy for stroke survivors compared with a control group on usual or standard of care.
This search yielded 49 abstracts. By consensus between 2 investigators, 22 publications met the criteria for inclusion and further review. Tele-rehabilitation interventions focused on motor recovery (n = 18), depression, or caregiver strain (n = 2) and higher cortical dysfunction (n = 2). Overall, tele-rehabilitation interventions were associated with significant improvements in recovery from motor deficits, higher cortical dysfunction, and depression in the intervention groups in all studies assessed, but significant differences between intervention versus control groups were reported in 8 of 22 studies in favor of tele-rehabilitation group while the remaining studies reported nonsignificant differences.
This updated systematic review provides evidence to suggest that tele-rehabilitation interventions have either better or equal salutary effects on motor, higher cortical, and mood disorders compared with conventional face-to-face therapy.
Copyright © 2018 National Stroke Association. All rights reserved.
[Abstract] Dual-task training effects on motor and cognitive functional abilities in individuals with stroke: a systematic review
This systematic review aimed to examine the effects of dual-task balance and mobility training in people with stroke.
An extensive electronic databases literature search was conducted using MEDLINE, PubMed, EBSCO, The Cochrane Library, Web of Science, SCOPUS, and Wiley Online Library. Randomized controlled studies that assessed the effects of dual-task training in stroke patients were included for the review (last search in December 2017). The methodological quality was evaluated using the Cochrane Collaboration recommendation, and level of evidence was determined according to the criteria described by the Oxford Center for Evidence-Based Medicine.
About 13 articles involving 457 participants were included in this systematic review. All had substantial risk of bias and thus provided level IIb evidence only. Dual-task mobility training was found to induce more improvement in single-task walking function (standardized effect size = 0.14–2.24), when compared with single-task mobility training. Its effect on dual-task walking function was not consistent. Cognitive-motor balance training was effective in improving single-task balance function (standardized effect size = 0.27–1.82), but its effect on dual-task balance ability was not studied. The beneficial effect of dual-task training on cognitive function was provided by one study only and thus inconclusive.
Stroke is one of the leading causes for disability worldwide . Motor function deficits due to stroke affects the patient’s mobility and contribute to overall quality of life. Neurorehabilitation training is the most effective way to reduce motor impairments in stroke patients. Conventional rehabilitation found to provide modest and sometimes delayed effects. This systematic review focuses on the impact of Virtual Reality Program on motor rehabilitation of stroke patients. The studies suggested that virtual reality is relatively recent approach that may enable practice of functional tasks at higher dosage than traditional therapies. From this review of literature , it can be concluded that Virtual Reality is effective in improving motor functions following stroke. Use of Virtual Reality as an adjunct to conventional therapy resulted in greater motor gains than conventional therapy alone . The studies included in this review show optimal level of evidence and grade of recommendations , but further studies with larger sample sizes are needed to draw more reliable conclusion.
Full Text: PDF
Ralph L. Sacco, Scott E. Kasner, Joseph P. Broderick, et,al on behalf of the American Heart Association Stroke Council Stroke. 2013;44:2064-2089.
Mozaffarian D, Benjamin EJ, Go AS, Arnett DK, Blaha MJ, Cushman M, Das SR, de Ferranti S, Despres JP, Fullerton HJ, et al. Heart disease and strokeStatistics2016 update: a report from the American Heart Association Circulation. 2016;133:e38– e60.
Wilkinson PR, Wolfe CD, Warburton FG, Rudd AG, Howard RS, Ross-Russell RW, Beech RR. A long-term follow-up of stroke patients. Stroke. 1997;28: 507–12.
Donnan GA, Fisher M, Macleod M, Davis SM: Stroke. Lancet 2008, 371:1612–1623.
Hochstenbach J, Prigatano G, Mulder T: Patients’ and relatives’ reports of disturbances 9 months after stroke: subjective changes in physical functioning, cognition, emotion, and behavior. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2005, 86:1587–1593.
Kaplan PE, Cailliet R, Kaplan CP: Rehabilitation of stroke. 1st edition. Burlington:
Townsend N, Wickramasinghe K, Bhatnagar P, Smolina K, NichoM (2012). Coronary heart disease statistics 2012 edition. British Heart Foundation: London.
Ng YS, Stein J, Ning M, Black-Schaffer RM: Comparison of clinical characteristics and functional outcomes of ischemic stroke in different vascular territories. Skitroke 2007;38:2309–2314.
Balaban B, Tok F, Yavuz F, Yasar E, Alaca R: Early rehabilitation outcome in patients with middle cerebral artery stroke. Neurosci Lett 2011;498:204–207.
Davidoff RA: The pyramidal tract. Neurology 1990;40:332–339.
Parker VM, Wade DT, Langton HR. Loss of arm function after stroke: measurement, frequency, and recovery. Int Rehabil Med. 1986;8:69–73.
Weinstein CJ, Stein J, Arena R, et al. Guidelines for adult stroke rehabilitation and recovery: a guideline for healthcare professionals from the American Heart Association/American Stroke Association. Stroke. 2016;47:e98–e169
Kleim JA, Jones TA. Principles of experience-dependent neural plasticity: implications for rehabilitation after brain damage. J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2008;51:S225–39.
Ward N. Treatment of arm and hand dysfunction after CNS damage. In: Oxford Textbook of Neurorehabilitation. Edited by Dietz V, Ward NS. Oxford; 2015. 238–250.
Bobath, B. (1990). Adult Hemiplegia: Evaluation and Treatment, 3rd Edn. Oxford: Heinemann Medical Books.
Ada, L., and Canning, C. (eds.). “Anticipating and avoiding muscle shortening,” in KeyIssues in Neurological Physiotherapy ,Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann ,1990; 219– 236.
Mudie, M. H., and Matyas, T. A. Upper extremity retraining following stroke: effects of bilateral practice. Neurorehabil. Neural Repair 1996; 10, 167–184.
Morris, D. M., Taub, E., and Mark, V. W. Constraint-induced movement therapy: characterizing the intervention protocol. Eura. Medicophys 2006 ; 42, 257–268.
Stefan, K., Kunesch, E., Cohen, L. G., Benecke, R., and Classen, J. Induction of plasticity in the human motor corte by paired associative stimulation. Brain 2000 ;123, 572–584.
Altschuler, E. L., Wisdom, S. B., Stone, L., Foster, C., Galasko, D., Llewellyn, D. M., et al. Rehabilitation of hemiparesis after stroke with a mirror. Lancet 1999 ;353, 2035– 2036.
Ramachandran, V. S., Rogers-Ramachandran, D., and Cobb, S. Touching the phantom limb. Nature 1995 ; 377, 489–490.
Oujamaa, L., Relave, I., Froger, J., Mottet, D., and Pelissier, J. Y. Rehabilitation of arm function after stroke. Literature review. Ann. Phys. Rehabil. Med. 2009; 52, 269–293.
Pignolo, L. Robotics in neuro-rehabilitation. J. Rehabil. Med. 2009 ; 41, 955–960.
Stefan, K., Kunesch, E., Cohen, L. G., Benecke, R., and Classen, J. Induction of plasticity in the human motor corte by paired associative stimulation. Brain 2000 ;123, 572–584.
Kwakkel G, Van Peppen R, Wagenaar R, Wood Dauphinee S, Richards C, Ashburn A, et al. Effects of augmented exercise therapy time after stroke. A meta-analysis.
Sisto S. A., Forrest G. F., Glendinning D. Virtual reality applications for motor rehabilitation after stroke. Topics in Stroke Rehabilitation. 2002;8(4):11–23.
Lange B., Koenig S., Chang C.-Y., et al. Designing informed game-based rehabilitation tasks leveraging advances in virtual reality. Disability and Rehabilitation. 2012;34(22):1863–1870.
Riva .G Virtual environments in clinical psychology. Psychotherapy 2003; 40:68
Sivan, M., O’Connor, R. J., Makower, S., Levesley, M., and Bhakta, B. Systematic review of outcome measures used in the evaluation of robot-assisted upper limb exercise in stroke. J. Rehabil. Med. 2011; 43, 181–189.
Oujamaa L., Relave I., Froger J., et al., Rehabilitation of arm function after stroke. Literature review. Ann. Phys. Rehabil. Med. 2009 ; 52, 269–293.
Turolla, A., Dam, M., Ventura, L., Tonin, P., et al., Virtual reality for the rehabilitation of the upper limb motor function after stroke: A prospective controlled trial. Journal of NeuroEngineering andRehabilitation, 2013 ,10(1), 85.
Daniel Perez-Marcos,OdileChevalley , Increasing upper limb training intensity in chronic stroke using embodied virtual reality: a pilot study Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation 2017 ;14:119.
Maureen K Holden, Virtual environments for motor rehabilitation: review.Cyber psychology and Behaviour. 2005 ;8(3) ,207.
Calabrò, R. S., Naro, A., Russo, M., Leo, A., De Luca, R., Balletta, T., … Bramanti, P. The role of virtual reality in improving motor performance as revealed by EEG: a randomized clinical trial. Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation,2017 ; 14(1), 53.
Jang SH, You SH, Hallett M, Cho YW, Park C-M, Cho S-H, Lee H-Y, Kim T-H. Cortical reorganization and associated functional motor recovery after virtual reality in patients with chronic stroke: an experimenter-blind preliminary study . Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2005;86:2218-23.
Schuster-Amft, Corina, Henneke, Andrea, Hartog-Keisker, Birgit, Holper, Lisa,
Siekierka, Ewa, Chevrier, Edith, Pyk, Pawel, Kollias, Spyros, Kiper, Daniel, Eng, Kynan , Intensive virtual reality-based training for upper limb motor function in chronic stroke: a feasibility study using a single case experimental design and fMRI. Disability & Rehabilitation: Assistive Technology, 2015, 10(5),385-392 .
Sergei V. Adamovich, Gerard G. Fluet, Eugene Tunik,and Alma S . Merians, Sensorimotor Training in Virtual Reality: A Review. Neurorehabilitation .2009 ; 25(1): 29.
Iris Brunner, Jan Sture Skouen, Håkon Hofstad, et al., Is upper limb virtual reality training more intensive than conventional training for patients in the subacute phase after stroke? An analysis of treatment intensity and content. BMC Neurology 2016 16:219.
Lee SJ, Chun MH. Combination transcranial direct current stimulations and virtual reality therapy for upper extremity training in patients with subacute stroke. Arch Phys Med Rehabil .2014 ;95:431-8.
Saposnik G, Levin M. Virtual reality in stroke rehabilitation: a meta-analysis and implications for clinicians. Stroke.2011; 42:1380-6.
Krichevets AN Sirotkina EB, Yevsevicheva IV, Zeldin LM Computer games as a means of movement rehabilitation. Disabil Rehabil. 1995 ;17(2):100-5.
Laver K, George S, Thomas S, et al., Virtual reality for stroke rehabilitation: an abridged version of a Cochrane review. Eur J Phys Rehabil Med. 2015 ;51(4):497–506.
Sang-Mi Jung, Won-Ho Choi, Effects of virtual reality intervention on upper limb motor function and activity of daily living in patients with lesions in different regions of the brain. J. Phys. Ther. Science 2017. 29(12) 2103-2106.
Fitzgerald, S. G., Cooper, R. A., Thorman, T., Cooper, R., Guo, S., and Boninger, M.
L. The game(cycle) exercise system: comparison with standard ergometry. J. Spinal. Cord. Med 2004; 27, 453–459.
Laver, K. E., George, S., Thomas, S., Deutsch, J. E., and Crotty, M. (2011). Virtual reality for stroke rehabilitation. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 9:Cd008349.
Richard J. Adams, Matthew D. Lichter , Allison Ellington ,et al., Virtual Activities of Daily Living for Recovery of Upper Extremity Motor Function IEEE Transactions on Neural Systems and Rehabilitation Engineering(2018),26(1),252-260.
Rachel C. Stockley, Deborah A. O’Connor, et al., Mixed Methods Small Pilot Study to Describe the Effects of Upper Limb Training Using a Virtual Reality Gaming System in People with Chronic Stroke. Rehabil Res Pract. 2017;2017:9569178.
Merians AS, Jack D, Boian R, Tremaine M, Burdea GC, AdamovichSV, et al. Virtual reality-augmented rehabilitation for patients following stroke. Phys Ther. 2002;82:898915.
Cameirão MS, Badia SB, Duarte E, Frisoli A, Verschure PFMJ. The combined impact of virtual reality neurorehabilitation and its interfaces on upper extremity functional recovery in patients with chronic stroke. Stroke. 2012;43:2720-8.
Boian R, Sharma A, Han C, Merians A, Burdea G, Adamovich S, Tremaine M, Poizner H Virtual reality-based post-stroke hand rehabilitation , Stud Health Technol Inform
Flexo-glove is a 3D printed soft exoskeleton robotic glove with compact and streamlined design for assistance in activities of daily livings and rehabilitation purposes of patients with hand function impairment.
- Overall weight of 330g including battery
- Providing 22N pinch force, 48N power grasp force and object grasp size of up to 81mm in diameter
- Two control modes: intention-sensing via wireless surface EMG for assistive mode and externally-directed via an accompanying smartphone
Project Details: —> Visit site
- Initiated the project with the idea of using soft 3D printed materials in design of the Flexo-glove inspired by X-Limb
- Performed feasibility study for using cable-driven mechanism in actuation of rehabilitation glove
- Leading a group of four mechatronics engineering students to fabricate the prototype and characterise the grip forces
- Received Dyason fellowship, $5000 travel fellowship awarded by Melbourne Robotic Lab. to visit Harvard BioRobotics Lab
Flexo-glove: A 3D Printed Soft Exoskeleton Robotic Glove for Impaired Hand Rehabilitation and Assistance
40th International Engineering in Medicine and Biology Conference (EMBC), 2018.
Full Text PDF
Virtual reality is mostly known as a platform for gamers — allowing its users to escape from the real world by commanding the Enterprise, rescuing their child from a post-apocalyptic wasteland or being transported smack-dab into the middle of a murder mystery.
However, there’s another angle at play.
It can also help alleviate symptoms and improve the health of people who’ve suffered illnesses and injuries.
Patients who have suffered stroke, dementia and traumatic brain injuries are using virtual reality as part of their rehabilitation therapy, thanks to technology developed by Bright Cloud International Corp.
BCI, a Rutgers University spinoff, announced earlier this month it moved its operations into the New Jersey Economic Development Authority’s Commercialization Center for Innovative Technologies in North Brunswick. The move will expand the CCIT’s footprint in New Jersey as a life sciences incubator.
“Having spent the past 30 years here, I know the intrinsic value that New Jersey offers entrepreneurs, including its strong academic institutions and its dynamic life sciences community. I also wanted to maintain strong ties with Rutgers and to offer jobs for students and graduates. In return for the decades of support I have received from the university, I wanted to strengthen BCI while also benefitting Rutgers,” said Grigore “Greg” Burdea, BCI founder and president.
The rehabilitation system, known as BrightBrainer, is a self-contained and mobile rehabilitation medical device that has custom virtual reality therapy games.
The system, which is available for lease or purchase, targets motor skills such as motor control, speed of movement, endurance, hand-eye coordination and task sequencing. It also targets cognitive abilities, including attention, short-term visual and auditory memory, working memory, reading comprehension and dual tasking.
The virtual reality system, according to BCI, is useful in a variety of health care settings, including outpatient clinics, skilled nursing facilities and medical adult day programs.
“Our biggest success to date is the BrightBrainer rehabilitation system. I am proud that it reduces care costs, increases access to care and improves therapy outcomes,” Burdea said.
A team of researchers, engineers, physicians, therapists and game developers created the games, which adapt to each individual patient.
According to BCI, BrightBrainer has been found to benefit a patient’s motor and cognitive skills, as well as a patient’s emotional state, leading to an increased quality of life.
“We know that the brain can rewire itself to bypass non-working neurons, so our technology helps patients build that bypass to regain use of their bodies,” Burdea said. “It also puts a new and interactive spin on the monotony of occupational therapy, bringing an age-old industry into the 21st century.”
Burdea said he moved the incubator to CCIT because of its environment, access to networking and investors, and opportunities for increased visibility.
“Understanding and responding to the needs of the market is imperative to the state’s ability to retain and attract innovative companies and top talent,” EDA CEO Tim Sullivan said. “Nurturing early-stage companies is just one facet of Gov. (Phil) Murphy’s vision of a more robust and equitable economy, and CCIT offers a model of what can be achieved through collaboration between the private, public and academic sectors.”
[BOOK] Emerging Therapies in Neurorehabilitation II – [Chapter] Virtual Rehabilitation – Request PDF
Virtual Rehabilitation | Request PDF. Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/300324828_Virtual_Rehabilitation
[ARTICLE] Low-Frequency Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation for Stroke-Induced Upper Limb Motor Deficit: A Meta-Analysis – Full Text
Background and Purpose. This meta-analysis aimed to evaluate the therapeutic potential of low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (LF-rTMS) over the contralesional hemisphere on upper limb motor recovery and cortex plasticity after stroke. Methods. Databases of PubMed, Medline, ScienceDirect, Cochrane, and Embase were searched for randomized controlled trials published before Jun 31, 2017. The effect size was evaluated by using the standardized mean difference (SMD) and a 95% confidence interval (CI). Resting motor threshold (rMT) and motor-evoked potential (MEP) were also examined. Results. Twenty-two studies of 1 Hz LF-rTMS over the contralesional hemisphere were included. Significant efficacy was found on finger flexibility (SMD = 0.75), hand strength (SMD = 0.49), and activity dexterity (SMD = 0.32), but not on body function (SMD = 0.29). The positive changes of rMT (SMD = 0.38 for the affected hemisphere and SMD = −0.83 for the unaffected hemisphere) and MEP (SMD = −1.00 for the affected hemisphere and SMD = 0.57 for the unaffected hemisphere) were also significant. Conclusions. LF-rTMS as an add-on therapy significantly improved upper limb functional recovery especially the hand after stroke, probably through rebalanced cortical excitability of both hemispheres. Future studies should determine if LF-rTMS alone or in conjunction with practice/training would be more effective. Clinical Trial Registration Information. This trial is registered with unique identifier CRD42016042181.
Stroke is a global disease with high rates of long-term disability . Around the world, 25%–74% of stroke survivors require different levels of assistance for daily living mainly due to upper limb hemiplegia . In search for better therapies, scientists have been trying to understand the relationship between stroke motor recovery and cortical reorganization . The equilibrium of cortical excitability between the two hemispheres is often disrupted after stroke. In the affected hemisphere, both the cortical excitability and the homonymous motor representation of the affected hemisphere decrease; whereas the excitability in the unaffected hemisphere increases .
Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) is a noninvasive stimulation to induce electrical currents in the brain tissues. Currently, rTMS is being explored as a novel therapy in modulating cortical excitability to improve motor functions in stroke patients . Of the two forms of rTMS, high-frequency rTMS (HF-rTMS > 1.0 Hz), applied over the ipsilesional hemisphere, facilitates cortical excitability , whereas, low-frequency rTMS (LF-rTMS ≤ 1.0 Hz), applied over the contralesional hemisphere, decreases cortical excitability .
The effect of rTMS is primarily determined by the stimulation frequency  and targeted region . Although both LF-rTMS and HF-rTMS could treat motor dysfunction in poststroke patients, LF-rTMS is considered safer and superior to HF-rTMS in motor function recovery [9–12]. Lomarev et al.  reported increased risk for seizures by HF-rTMS of 20–25 Hz. To date, the majority of rTMS trials on motor recovery after stroke used the protocol of LF-rTMS with 1 Hz. In comparison, the HF-rTMS studies involved only a small number of trials and applied varied frequency protocols (3 Hz to 25 Hz). According to Cho et al. , the primary motor cortex (M1) forms a main part of the motor cortices and contributes to the high order control of motor behaviors. Until now, most studies about the efficacy of LF-rTMS on functional rehabilitation have focused on the M1. In healthy subjects, LF-rTMS applied over the M1 increased the resting motor threshold (rMT) and decreased the motor-evoked potential (MEP) size of the ipsilateral hemisphere, suggesting a suppressive effect of LF-rTMS in the intact M1 .
Multiple studies have investigated the therapeutic effect of LF-rTMS after stroke [8, 16–19], with the outcomes of pinch force [19–22], grip force [10, 22–25], finger tapping [8, 9, 26–29], and overall function [15, 30–34]. Other studies also explored the impact of rTMS on cortical excitability [10, 18, 19, 26]. However, inconsistent reports exist regarding the benefits of LF-rTMS: Some studies showed no beneficial effect of LF-rTMS [16, 23, 29] and one study reported worsening effects of LF-rTMS such as decreased finger-tapping speed;  other investigators proposed that inhibition of the contralesional motor areas may lead to deterioration of the function of the unaffected hand [24, 26]. Although a few previous meta-analyses had investigated the therapeutic effect of rTMS after stroke [11, 36–38], they focused on the mixed effect of combined LF-rTMS and HF-rTMS interventions or on the combined outcomes of varying motor measurements. So far, there is a lack of in-depth systematic meta-analysis about the efficacy of LF-rTMS on upper limb function recovery.
The primary objective of this study was to evaluate the effects of LF-rTMS on upper limb motor recovery after stroke in several aspects: “finger flexibility,” “hand strength,” “activity dexterity,” and “body function level.” The effects of LF-rTMS on motor cortex excitability which were represented by MEP and rMTin poststroke patients were also evaluated. […]